American Idol, how could I be so wrong?

Update 4/7/04 – OK, what the heck is going on here?! How in the world is John Stevens surviving? It can not be on talent. Unbelievable. See ya Camile. I thought you’d make it a few more weeks.

If you watch the show, you probably have your own opinions as to who is any good and who is not so good. Well, so do I, and I’m taking a shot at picking what order people will place given my opinion of their talent.

Here we go:

1 – La Toya London 2 – George Huff 3 – Fantasia Barrino 4 – Jennifer Hudson 5 – Jasmine Trias 6 – Diana DeGarmo 7 – Camile Velasco 8 – Jon Peter Lewis 9 – John Stevens 10 – Amy Adams *

Remember, I’m basing this on my opinion of their performances. I may change it as time goes on because I am not 100% comfortable in the Top 5 rankings since anything can happen and they stay or go based on people phoning in votes.

* – I was already wrong, so I had to adjust before I even posted this! Amy deserved much better than this. She truly has talent. On the other hand, John Stevens, while a fantastic Dean Martin impersonator, is not that great of a singer. Not only should he have been voted out tonight on the basis of his awful performance, but he never should have made it anywhere near this far in the first place.

Comments are closed.